Ultimate Avengers is a straight-to-video animated movie loosly based on the Marvel comic book The Ultimates.
First of all, some background:
Marvel Comics has recently started a new “universe” of comic books where they take some of their classic comics of the past and re-issue them with new artists and writers, but with similar (although not exactly the same) backstories. So far, they have created Ultimate X-Men, Ultimate SpiderMan, Ultimate Fantastic Four and the Ultimates (which is based on the classic comic, the Avengers.) There might be some others, that I’m not aware of. My roommate collects all of these books, so he’d know more than I do.
So, when we saw the ads for the Ultimate Avengers, we were interested, yet a bit wary. However, when it came out, I dropped it to #1 on my Netflix Queue and we watched it last week.
The plotline roughly followed the plot of the Ultimates comic book. It began a few days after World War 2 was over. Hitler was dead, but some of the German officers were plotting to use some sort of “Super Weapon”. Captain America and a group of Army soldiers are tasked with storming the compound where this Super Weapon is stored. In the course of this battle, it is discovered that the Nazi soldiers are NOT Nazi’s at all, but are aliens. They manage to launch the weapon, but not before Captain America grabbed onto it. Captain America rides the rocket and after fighting off some of the aliens disables it over the Arctic sea, but the device explodes, and Captain America is lost. (This follows the basic plotline of the original Avengers comic.)
Years later, Nick Fury and S.H.I.E.L.D (I’ll make you look up what that stands for) are trying to discover the secret of the Super Soldier Serum which was injected into Captain America many years ago. They are working to start up a team of Super Heroes to work for the Government in their Avengers Program. They find Captain America embedded deep into a glacier and eventually discover that he is alive. Before long the aliens that Cap fought so many years ago are back and the newly formed team must overcome their own inner conflicts and fight them.
The good:
I’ll start off by saying that I enjoyed this. As a typical straight-to-video animated movie, it was pretty entertaining. It had a degree of violence which included soldiers dying. However, it appears that their goal was to include enough violence to draw the Adult comic fans but rein it in enough that most parents won’t balk at the idea of their children seeing it. In that, I would say that they achieved their goal well. The plotline will be familiar to fans of either the Ultimates or the older Avengers comic.
Now for the bad:
Considering that they are obviously basing this off of the Ultimates comic, and are trying to draw the fans of that story, I think they deviated from the story a bit too much. Yes, they had the basic plot points. But they changed enough of it that any real fan of the Ultimates will probably be left somewhat disappointed. They shouldn’t have tied this work so closely to the Ultimates if they weren’t willing to go all the way with the story. So, small (but in my opinion, important) sub-plots were left out. The character Hank Pym (who is both Ant-Man and Giant-Man) is no longer the bi-polar mess he is in the Ultimates book.
I was probably mostly disappointed in their characterization of Thor. In the Ultimates they made him basically a hippie tree-hugger. I never got the sense from the comic that he spoke with the lofty tones of the Thor from the main Marvel Universe. In the Ultimate Avengers, they seem to have mixed these two traits.
And I think that is where the movie loses its focus. It appears to be trying to mix the old with the new. I personally think they should have gone all the way, instead of trying to please everyone. I would say that this movie is not for the “hard-core fan” of the Ultimates, or of the old Avengers comic. Some will like it, some will absolutely hate it. I’m sure most will be like me. “It was okay.” If you’re interested in Super Heroes or animated movies, you may enjoy this as well.
Rating: 3.1